Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Employment Tribunal results

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Employment Tribunal results

    Just copied this from a FSB letter, shows a tribunal is not always against the employer

    Annual Tribunals Statistics show 8% fall in tribunal claims

    HM Courts and Tribunals Service has published its Annual Tribunals Statistics for the year 1 April 2010 to 31 March 2011. The report covers information on all tribunals but specifically in relation to employment tribunals:

    218,100 employment tribunal claims were received, representing an 8% fall on the previous year 2009/10 but a 44% increase on 2008/09. Compared to 2009/10, this comprised a 15% fall in single claims and a 4% fall in multiple claims.
    The number of jurisdictional claims was 382,400, meaning that there were on average 1.75 jurisdictions per claim. Of these, 30% related to working time claims (largely airline cases that are resubmitted every three months), 28% were for unfair dismissal, breach of contract and redundancy and 19% were for unauthorised deductions from wages.
    There has been a steady increase in the number of age discrimination claims being brought in employment tribunals, with the number rising from 3,800 in 2008/09 to 5,200 in 2009/10 and 6,800 in 2010/11.
    Of the claims that were disposed of over the year, 32% were withdrawn, 29% were ACAS conciliated, 10% were struck out (not at a hearing), 2% were dismissed at a preliminary hearing, 12% were successful at tribunal, 9% were unsuccessful at tribunal and 6% were subject to a default judgment.
    Chris Ashdown

    #2
    Some interesting numbers there.

    Did they have any numbers on the percentage of claims that were sucessful and how many were 'disposed'.

    Mike
    -----------------------------------------

    First Tackle - Fly Fishing and Game Angling

    -----------------------------------------

    Comment


      #3
      Sorry no further details Mike, but may be some on ACAS site
      Chris Ashdown

      Comment


        #4
        interesting figures indeed,
        trouble is, the dice seems to be loaded against the employer.

        we ended up in a tribunal, unfair dismissal & race , and after day 1, the local newspaper printed "company unfair to coloured man", day2, our turn to speak, end of day2, total vindication and an apology from the paper.

        so far, three tribunals, three victories for the company, and each time,we came out vindicated

        Comment


          #5
          OK. I misunderstood the terminology. 'Disposals' are the cases that were dealt with.

          So, if I understand these correctly. 82% of claims did not result in a win at tribunal:

          - 32% were withdrawn.
          - 29% acas conciliated (presumably large / union backed cases).
          - 10% struck out. (Employee didn't turn up?)
          - 2% dismissed at a preliminary hearing.
          - 9% failed at tribunal.

          18% succeeded:

          - 12% won at tribunal
          - 6% default judgement (Employer didn't turn up?)

          Or if we ignore the acas ones then roughly:

          1/3rd of the cases get withdrawn
          1/3rd of the cases the employer wins
          1/3rd of the cases the ex-employee wins

          Which sounds about right. I'm sure there are some bad employers out there, just as there can be bad employees. So probably the right decision gets made most of the time.

          Mike
          -----------------------------------------

          First Tackle - Fly Fishing and Game Angling

          -----------------------------------------

          Comment

          Working...
          X